Maun Responds to IR Readers

from LTC Joe Maun in Iraq

I have received a couple of e-mails and there were a couple of postings asking me what special position I have to make such predictions about attacks in the US ("These people wi'll follow us home" ) should we leave Iraq without getting the job done.

I would like to address just that. For the record I serve on a General Staff as part of the reconstruction effort. Daily I see reports of fanatics killing Iraqis for associating with Americans. I am not a trained Intel officer nor do I regularly get classified intelligence briefing and even if I did I would not share it to suit my purpose. I have commanded two Battalions, one Combat Arms and one Combat Support. My career is over 30 years and I have attended the Command and General Staff College. I have studied and taught Military History. I can therefore evaluate facts and put together a reasonable estimate of events.

For those that think that this is not enough, the following came across my desk this morning with the world news (Please note that well trained American fighting men and women got Al-Zarqawi over here in Iraq before he could carry out his mission and have the "read him his rights" and "it is America's fault" crowd making excuses for him after he killed more Americans.)

WASHINGTON (AP) - President Bush, trying to defend his war strategy, declassified intelligence Tuesday asserting that Osama bin Laden ordered a top lieutenant in early 2005 to form a terrorist cell that would conduct attacks outside Iraq - and that the United States should be the top target.

The information mirrored a classified bulletin from the Homeland Security Department in March 2005, reporting that bin Laden had enlisted Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, his senior operative in Iraq, to plan potential strikes in the U.S. The warning was described at the time as credible but not specific and did not prompt the administration to raise its national terror alert level.

The declassification of the intelligence came a day before Bush was scheduled to speak about terrorism at the U.S. Coast Guard Academy.

Bush, who is battling Democrats in Congress over spending for the unpopular war in Iraq, will argue that the terrorist threat to America is real, said Frances Fragos Townsend, the White House homeland security adviser. She said Bush would talk about why Iraq is an important battleground in fighting terrorism abroad to prevent attacks on U.S. soil and highlight previously reported successes in foiling terrorist attacks.

The Bush White House has intermittently declassified and made public sensitive intelligence information to help rebut critics or defend programs or actions against possibly adverse decisions in the Congress or the courts. On a few occasions, the declassified materials were intended as proof that terrorists see Iraq as a critical staging ground for global operations.

Democrats and other critics have accused Bush of selectively declassifying intelligence, including portions of a sensitive National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq, to justify the U.S.-led invasion on the ground that Saddam Hussein's regime possessed weapons of mass destruction. That assertion proved false.

Townsend, reading from notes, said the declassified intelligence showed that in January 2005, bin Laden tasked al-Zarqawi with organizing the cell. Al-Zarqawi, the former leader of al-Qaida's Iraq operations, was killed there in June 2006 by a U.S. airstrike.

"We know from the intelligence community that al-Zarqawi welcomed the tasking and claimed he already had some good proposals," Townsend said.

She said that in the spring of 2005, bin Laden instructed Hamza Rabia, a senior operative, to brief al-Zarqawi on al-Qaida planning to attack sites outside Iraq, including the United States. She did not disclose where in the United States those attacks were being plotted.

Around the same time, Abu Fajah al-Libi, a senior al-Qaida manager, suggested that bin Laden send Rabia to Iraq to actually help al-Zarqawi plan the external operations, Townsend said. It is unclear whether Rabia went to Iraq, she said.

She said the information was declassified because the intelligence community has tracked all leads from the information.

LTC Joseph M. Maun

joseph.maun@us.army.mil